Tickmill vs XM: FX Trust Score Breakdown & Key Differences (2025)
Tickmill and XM are two globally respected forex brokers, each offering strong regulation, competitive trading conditions and accessible account options. This comparison uses the FX Trust Score Index, our independent scoring system that rates brokers across five key categories: Regulation, Security & Fund Protection, Trading Conditions, Customer Support and Online Reputation.
While both brokers perform well overall, they appeal to different types of traders. Tickmill is often preferred by active, cost-focused traders due to its low spreads and fast execution, whereas XM is popular among beginners and intermediate traders thanks to its educational resources and flexible account structures.
The side-by-side comparison below shows exactly how both brokers stack up across all FX Trust Score pillars.
Side-by-Side Performance Across All FX Trust Score Pillars
| Criterion | Tickmill Review | XM Review |
|---|---|---|
| Overall FX Trust Score | 80.75% | 78.9% |
| Regulatory Compliance | 90% | 80% |
| Security & Fund Protection | 80% | 80% |
| Trading Conditions | 75% | 75% |
| Customer Support | 70% | 78% |
| Online Reputation | 80% | 80% |
Comparison Summary: Pepperstone vs AvaTrade
Here’s how both brokers typically compare across the main FX Trust Score categories:
Regulation
Both Tickmill and XM hold multiple reputable regulatory licences. Tickmill often secures a slight advantage due to its particularly strong compliance in key jurisdictions, while XM also maintains solid regulatory coverage across several regions worldwide.
Security & Fund Protection
Security levels are strong for both brokers, with segregated funds and strict operational processes. Tickmill may score marginally higher due to transparent internal risk controls and strong reputation for fairness. XM remains a safe, long-established broker with a strong operational track record.
Trading Conditions
This is where Tickmill typically stands out.
- Tickmill is known for:
- low variable spreads,
- fast execution speed,
- minimal slippage,
- and cost-effective ECN-style trading.
XM performs very well, especially for:
- beginners,
- small accounts,
- micro lots,
- consistent execution across global regions.
But Tickmill normally earns the higher FX Trust Score for raw pricing and speed.
Customer Support
XM often leads in customer support due to:
- wider language availability,
- better educational materials,
- more accessible regional coverage.
Tickmill offers solid support too, but XM typically edges ahead in this category.
Online Reputation
XM has a significantly larger user base globally, leading to higher overall sentiment visibility. Tickmill is also highly regarded, especially by experienced traders who favour its low-cost model.
XM usually wins this category due to broader reach and brand familiarity.
Overall Winner: Tickmill (slightly)
Based on the FX Trust Score Index, Tickmill typically wins overall thanks to its strong trading conditions, excellent execution performance and solid regulatory standing.
However, XM remains one of the best beginner-friendly brokers in the world and is often preferred by traders who value:
- flexible account types,
- educational content,
- low minimum deposits,
- strong multilingual support.
Both brokers are excellent and your choice depends on your experience level and trading priorities.
Comparison: Winners Summary
Regulation
- Winner: Tickmill
Stronger compliance structure across key markets.
Security & Fund Protection
- Winner: Tickmill (slightly)
High transparency and strong fund protection.
Trading Conditions
- Winner: Tickmill
Low spreads, fast execution and competitive pricing.
Customer Support
- Winner: XM
Better language support and educational materials.
Online Reputation
- Winner: XM
Larger global user base and long-standing reputation.
Conclusion: Which Broker is Better Overall?
Choose Tickmill if you want:
- ultra-competitive spreads
- fast execution
- a low-cost ECN-style environment
- tight pricing ideal for day trading or scalping
Choose XM if you prefer:
- beginner-friendly accounts
- flexible trade sizes
- strong educational resources
- multilingual global support
Both brokers are safe, reputable choices – pick the one that best aligns with your trading experience and goals.
FAQs
Both brokers are well-regulated, but Tickmill often has a slight edge in compliance strength.
Tickmill typically offers tighter spreads and more cost-effective trading.
XM is usually preferred by beginners for its simpler accounts and educational content.
Tickmill generally offers faster execution with less slippage.
Yes , both hold multiple reputable regulatory licences.
Publication date:
22/11/2025
Author: FX Trust Score
Last updated on November 22, 2025
