Pepperstone vs Tickmill: FX Trust Score Breakdown & Key Differences (2025)
This in-depth comparison examines Pepperstone vs Tickmill using the FX Trust Score Index, our independent, data-driven scoring model designed to give traders a clear, unbiased view of how each forex broker performs across regulation, security standards, trading conditions, customer support quality and online reputation.
Our goal is simple: help you determine which broker is the better fit for your trading needs by presenting a transparent, side-by-side breakdown of strengths and weaknesses. Whether your priorities involve low-cost trading conditions, platform performance, regulatory safety or multilingual customer support, this guide highlights the facts that matter most.
Below, you’ll find a clear comparison table showing how both brokers performed across our six FX Trust Score pillars, followed by deeper insights and a conclusion to help you make a confident decision.
Side-by-Side Performance Across All FX Trust Score Pillars
| Criterion | Pepperstone Review | Tickmill Review |
|---|---|---|
| Overall FX Trust Score | 83.5% | 80.75% |
| Regulatory Compliance | 80% | 90% |
| Security & Fund Protection | 85% | 80% |
| Trading Conditions | 80% | 75% |
| Customer Support | 90% | 70% |
| Online Reputation | 85% | 80% |
Comparison Summary: Pepperstone vs Tickmill
Here is how both brokers typically compare across the FX Trust Score Index:
Regulation
Both Pepperstone and Tickmill maintain strong, multi-jurisdiction regulation. Pepperstone benefits from stricter oversight in several regions, while Tickmill holds an equally credible set of licences across Europe and offshore locations.
Security
Both brokers offer solid fund protection standards, including segregation of client funds. Pepperstone scored slightly higher overall due to broader internal safeguards and operational controls.
Trading Conditions
Pepperstone offers slightly more competitive spreads and execution speed, particularly for active traders and algorithmic strategies. Tickmill remains highly competitive, especially in its Pro and VIP accounts.
Customer Support
Tickmill leads in support responsiveness and multilingual coverage, offering faster average reply times based on our evaluation.
Online Reputation
Both brokers maintain strong reputations, but Pepperstone edges ahead due to consistently positive trader sentiment across multiple regions.
Overall Winner: Pepperstone
Based on our FX Trust Score Index, Pepperstone finishes narrowly ahead of Tickmill, offering stronger trading conditions, excellent regulatory protection and consistently positive long-term reputation data. For most traders, Pepperstone provides the more balanced, stable and competitive overall experience.
However, Tickmill remains an excellent alternative, particularly for traders who prioritise low-cost raw spread accounts or require strong multilingual support.
Comparison: Winners Summary
Regulation
- Winner: Pepperstone
Both brokers are well regulated, with Pepperstone showing marginally stronger oversight in key regions.
Security & Fund Protection
- Winner: Pepperstone
Pepperstone leads slightly due to enhanced operational safeguards and broader security controls.
Trading Conditions
- Winner: Pepperstone
Pepperstone provides tighter spreads and faster execution, especially for high-speed and automated strategies.
Customer Support
- Winners: Tickmill
Tickmill outperforms with quicker response times and wider language coverage.
Online Reputation
- Winner: Pepperstone
Pepperstone scores higher overall due to stable long-term trader sentiment and fewer negative consistency indicators.
Conclusion: Which Broker is Better Overall?
Choosing between Pepperstone and Tickmill depends on what matters most to your trading.
Pepperstone is the stronger all-round choice, offering tighter spreads, sharp execution quality, reliable support and a long-standing reputation built across multiple top-tier regulatory jurisdictions. It suits most traders, especially those using EAs, scalping or high-frequency strategies.
Tickmill remains a top competitor, especially for cost-conscious traders seeking ultra-low spreads and multilingual support. It offers a clean, stable trading environment and continues to grow its global reputation.
For most traders, Pepperstone delivers the better complete package across all FX Trust Score pillars. However, both brokers are trusted, well-regulated and suitable for a wide range of trading styles. We recommend reviewing each full broker review before making a final decision.
FAQs
Pepperstone performs better overall in our FX Trust Score Index, offering stronger trading conditions, regulatory protection and long-term reputation. Tickmill remains an excellent low-spread alternative.
Pepperstone offers marginally tighter average spreads across major currency pairs, though Tickmill is highly competitive in its Pro and VIP accounts.
Both brokers are suitable for beginners, though Pepperstone provides broader educational support and more intuitive platform options.
Both brokers are safe and regulated, but Pepperstone holds stronger oversight in multiple top-tier jurisdictions.
Both brokers offer MT4 and MT5. Pepperstone also provides cTrader, which appeals to algorithmic and professional traders.
Publication date:
23/11/2025
Author: FX Trust Score
Last updated on November 23, 2025
