AvaTrade vs eToro: FX Trust Score Breakdown & Key Differences (2025)
This in-depth comparison looks at AvaTrade vs eToro using the FX Trust Score Index, our independent scoring methodology that evaluates each broker across the same five key pillars: regulatory compliance, security and fund protection, trading conditions, customer support and online reputation.
Our aim is to give traders a clear, unbiased view of how these two high-profile brands compare, beyond the marketing and social media presence. Whether you’re drawn to eToro’s social trading model or AvaTrade’s strong educational focus and multi-platform offering, this guide will help you understand where each broker genuinely stands.
Below, you’ll find a side-by-side breakdown of how both brokers perform across all FX Trust Score pillars, followed by a winners summary, more detailed analysis and our overall verdict.
| Criterion | AvaTrade Review | eToro Review |
|---|---|---|
| Overall FX Trust Score | 85.75% | 74% |
| Regulatory Compliance | 90% | 85% |
| Security & Fund Protection | 90% | 80% |
| Trading Conditions | 85% | 60% |
| Customer Support | 80% | 68% |
| Online Reputation | 80% | 72% |
Comparison Summary: AvaTrade vs eToro
Regulation
Both AvaTrade and eToro are well regulated and authorised in major jurisdictions. AvaTrade holds licences across Europe, Australia, South Africa, Japan, the UAE and other regions, giving it a wide regulatory footprint and strong global coverage. eToro is also regulated in the UK, Europe and Australia, and is publicly listed, which adds a layer of transparency.
In our scoring, AvaTrade comes out ahead thanks to its broader mix of licences and long track record across several major regions.
Security & Fund Protection
Client fund segregation is standard at both brokers, and each follows established procedures for managing client money and operational risk. AvaTrade scores higher on security due to its combination of regulation, operational resilience and internal controls.
eToro remains a secure broker with robust oversight, but its lower FX Trust Score in this pillar compared with AvaTrade means AvaTrade is our preferred option from a pure security and protection standpoint.
Trading Conditions
AvaTrade and eToro take different approaches to trading conditions.
AvaTrade provides competitive spreads, a wide choice of platforms (including MT4, MT5 and proprietary systems) and solid execution across forex, indices, commodities and other CFDs. Its FX Trust Score for trading conditions reflects this balanced, trader-friendly environment.
eToro, on the other hand, focuses heavily on multi-asset investing and social trading. It offers a huge range of stocks, ETFs and crypto, but spreads on forex and CFD products can be higher and more variable, particularly during volatile periods. As a result, its trading-conditions score is notably lower than AvaTrade’s.
For traders who care most about forex and CFD pricing and execution, AvaTrade is the clear winner.
Customer Support
AvaTrade delivers strong 24/5 customer support via live chat, email and phone, with multiple local numbers and multilingual assistance. Response times and resolution quality tested well in our review, leading to a higher support score.
eToro offers support via tickets and live chat, but user feedback suggests response times can be inconsistent, and phone support is more limited. This is reflected in its lower customer-support score.
If responsive help and traditional support channels matter to you, AvaTrade has the edge.
Online Reputation
Both brokers are highly recognisable brands with large client bases. eToro especially is well known for its social trading and heavy marketing presence.
However, when we analyse longer-term sentiment, complaint patterns and user feedback quality, AvaTrade performs better overall. It scores higher on our online reputation pillar thanks to more stable feedback trends and fewer recurring concerns around spreads, slippage or service.
eToro remains popular and continues to evolve, but in our dataset AvaTrade has the stronger trust profile.
Overall Winner: AvaTrade
Based on the FX Trust Score Index, AvaTrade clearly outperforms eToro overall. AvaTrade scores higher in all five of our core pillars; regulation, security, trading conditions, customer support and online reputation.
However, eToro still has a strong proposition for certain trader types, particularly those who value its social/copy trading ecosystem and wide range of stocks and ETFs. It remains a well-known brand with a large global following, but from a pure “trust and trading quality” perspective, AvaTrade takes the lead.
Comparison: Winners Summary
Regulation
- Winner: AvaTrade
Broader regulatory coverage across multiple top-tier and mid-tier jurisdictions.
Security & Fund Protection
- Winner: AvaTrade
Strong fund segregation and robust safeguards, with higher overall security scoring than eToro.
Trading Conditions
- Winner: AvaTrade
More competitive overall trading conditions, particularly on spreads and derivatives offering.
Customer Support
- Winner: AvaTrade
Higher support score, with reliable 24/5 coverage and better overall client experience.
Online Reputation
- Winner: AvaTrade
More consistent long-term sentiment from traders and industry sources compared with eToro.
Conclusion: Which Broker is Better Overall?
Choosing between AvaTrade and eToro depends on what you’re looking for in a broker.
If you want a well-rounded forex and CFD broker with strong regulation, competitive conditions, multiple platforms (including MT4/MT5), solid education and a high FX Trust Score across all pillars, AvaTrade is the better choice for most traders.
If you prioritise social trading and multi-asset investing, particularly copying other traders or building a portfolio of stocks and ETFs, then eToro still has a compelling offering, as long as you are comfortable with higher average spreads on CFDs and some limitations in support.
From a pure trust and trading quality perspective, our FX Trust Score Index rates AvaTrade higher overall. We recommend reading both full reviews before you decide, especially if you have specific needs around products, platforms or regulation.
FAQs
According to our FX Trust Score Index, AvaTrade scores higher overall than eToro across all five pillars – regulation, security, trading conditions, customer support and online reputation. eToro still has strengths in social and copy trading, but AvaTrade is the stronger all-round broker.
AvaTrade generally offers more competitive spreads and overall trading conditions on forex and CFDs. eToro’s spreads can be wider and more variable, especially during periods of high volatility.
Both are regulated and considered safe, but AvaTrade holds a broader set of licences across multiple jurisdictions and scores higher on our security and regulation metrics. eToro is also well regulated and publicly listed, which adds transparency, but it ranks lower overall in our Index.
Both can work for beginners, but AvaTrade’s strong educational resources, clear platform options and balanced trading environment make it a very good choice. eToro is also beginner-friendly from a usability perspective, particularly for those mainly interested in copying other traders.
For long-term investing in stocks and ETFs or for social/copy trading, eToro has the stronger specialised offering. For active forex and CFD trading with a focus on pricing, platforms and classic brokerage features, AvaTrade is the preferred choice.
Publication date:
23/11/2025
Author: FX Trust Score
Last updated on November 23, 2025
